Really not sure why so many people struggle with that.
Just hazarding a guess here based on my own difficulties with it, but I suspect it has something to do with the fact the name is
very subject to differences in regional accents because of all the vowels.
In my accent and the accent I'm surrounded by every day, which is different from mine, "orl" and "all" sound nothing alike. At all. So trying to use both as a pronunciation key is very confusing for me. I get the similarities between the sounds intellectually, but since they don't really sound very close to my ear, I'm really just trying to shoot halfway between the suggested sounds rather than having a firm idea of how to say it based on them.
By the way, the differences in regional accents thing is not a criticism. Lots of names are like that. For example, consider how people say the name Dawn. It sounds
completely different depending on the region the speaker is from, but we don't think anything of it because for English speakers it's a familiar word. Because Aorle is unfamiliar, it causes more of an accent struggle.
I do feel more confident given the Eorle thing. I have a way of pronouncing that which may or may not be right, but which works well enough for my purposes, so I can pronounce Aorle in a similar way and be happy.
